Need help? National Domestic Violence Hotline 1-800-799-7233, or text START to 88788. In an emergency, call 911.Hotline 1-800-799-7233, or text START to 88788. Emergency: 911.

Understanding Coercive Control

12Jan 2027TuesdayPlanned

Episode 8: Should It Be a Crime?

Should Coercive Control Be a Crime? The Debate

Only one US state, Hawaii, makes coercive control a crime in itself, and five years in, nobody can say how often the law is used.

Episode
8 of 10
Running time
14:14
Sources
23, listed below
An empty jury box with leather chairs
Coming Jan 12The video will play here. Nothing loads from YouTube until you press play. The picture is an AI-generated illustration, not from the records.

This episode mentions a death by suicide. If you are thinking about suicide, call or text 988.

What this episode covers

This episode sets out what Hawaii's law says, what England and Wales, New South Wales and Canada have done, what survivors report about calling the police, and the strongest arguments for and against a new crime.

Law checked

13Nov 2026

Nov 13, 2026. State law was checked for Hawaii, New York and South Carolina; federal law was checked for one US Supreme Court decision and for the status of one pending federal prosecution, and no federal crime of coercive control was found. Laws change; check the current status in your state. Hawaii's offense is a pilot that now runs to June 30, 2031. New York's bill is pending. South Carolina's sponsor has said he will refile in January 2027.

About the cases

The court decisions come from the public record. We do not name the parties in narration; case names appear only as the courts captioned them. R v Chilvers is an English decision and is not US law. The material from England and Wales, Scotland, Ireland, New South Wales and Canada is a comparison point, not a US finding. The cold open quotes written testimony filed with the Hawaii Legislature. The federal charges described in the South Carolina case are allegations; the defendant has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Updates since recording

None so far.

Sources, in on-air order

23 sources. Each has its own link you can copy, for example episode-8.html#S-165.

  1. S-138

    Haw. Rev. Stat. § 586-1; § 709-906; Act 192 of 2026 (HB 1959)

    Statute · Hawaii

    Shown in the video as S-160

  2. S-162

    Hawaii Act 238, Session Laws 2021 (HB 566, HD 1, SD 1), with Governor's Message 1366 (July 7, 2021)

    Enacted law (act or session law) · Hawaii

  3. S-163

    Testimony on HB 566, HD 1, Hawaii Senate Committee on Judiciary (Mar. 19, 2021)

    Legislative record · Hawaii

  4. S-165

    The Judiciary, State of Hawaii, Report on Domestic Violence and Increased Offender Accountability, pursuant to Act 19, SLH 2020 (December 2025), Judiciary Comm. No. 8

    Government report · Hawaii

  5. S-166

    The Marshall Project, How 'Coercive Control' Is Expanding Domestic Abuse Laws in Several States, by Alysia Santo (June 28, 2025)

    News report · United States

  6. S-167

    New York Senate Bill S4079 / Assembly Bill A679 (2025-2026), establishing the crime of coercive control

    Bill · New York

  7. S-168

    South Carolina S. 702 (2025-2026), Criminal Coercive Control; WRDW, S.C. senator to reintroduce 'Mica's Law' targeting coercive control (June 30, 2026)

    Bill · South Carolina

  8. S-169

    UK Home Office, Review of the Controlling or Coercive Behaviour Offence (2021)

    Government report · United Kingdom

  9. S-170

    Office for National Statistics (UK), Domestic abuse and the criminal justice system, England and Wales: November 2025, with appendix tables 16 and 17

    Official statistics · United Kingdom

  10. S-062

    Office for National Statistics (UK), Domestic abuse prevalence and trends, England and Wales: year ending March 2025 (Nov. 26, 2025); and Redevelopment of domestic abuse statistics: research update May 2025

    Official statistics · United Kingdom

  11. S-171

    NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research, Coercive Control Monitoring Report, quarterly report December 2025 (published March 2026)

    Official statistics · Australia

  12. S-172

    Department of Justice Canada, Protecting Victims Act (Bill C-16) backgrounder

    Government summary of a bill · Canada

  13. S-173

    National Domestic Violence Hotline, Law Enforcement Experience Report (2022), report led by Leigh Goodmark

    Survey research by an advocacy organization · United States

  14. S-144

    BWJP, Coercive Control Codification: A Brief Guide for Advocates and Coalitions (November 2021)

    Advocacy organization resource · United States

    Shown in the video as S-174

  15. S-175

    Sheley, Criminalizing Coercive Control Within the Limits of Due Process, 70 Duke Law Journal 1321 (2021)

    Legal scholarship · United States

  16. S-176

    Cross, Coercive Control and the Limits of Criminal Law, 56 UC Davis Law Review 195 (2022)

    Legal scholarship · United States

  17. S-177

    R v Chilvers [2021] EWCA Crim 1311 (Court of Appeal of England and Wales, Criminal Division, Aug. 27, 2021)

    English appellate judgment (not US law) · United Kingdom

  18. S-178

    Counterman v. Colorado, 600 U.S. 66 (2023), No. 22-138 (June 27, 2023)

    US Supreme Court opinion · United States

  19. S-179

    Ireland, Domestic Violence Act 2018, section 39 (offence of coercive control)

    Enacted law (act or session law) · Ireland

  20. S-180

    U.S. Attorney's Office, District of South Carolina, Myrtle Beach Pastor Indicted for Cyberstalking Wife Before Her Death (press release, Dec. 18, 2025)

    Government press release · South Carolina

  21. S-181

    WPDE, Trial delayed for JP Miller, pastor at center of Netflix docuseries about Mica Miller (Sept. 23, 2026); FITSNews, Mica Miller Timeline (Sept. 1, 2026); Netflix Tudum (Aug. 26, 2026)

    News report · South Carolina

  22. S-010

    Campbell et al., Risk Factors for Femicide in Abusive Relationships: Results From a Multisite Case Control Study, American Journal of Public Health 93(7), 2003

    Peer-reviewed study · United States

  23. S-028

    Myhill & Hohl, The 'Golden Thread': Coercive Control and Risk Assessment for Domestic Violence, Journal of Interpersonal Violence 34(21-22), 2019

    Peer-reviewed study · United Kingdom