Need help? National Domestic Violence Hotline 1-800-799-7233, or text START to 88788. In an emergency, call 911.Hotline 1-800-799-7233, or text START to 88788. Emergency: 911.

Understanding Coercive Control

19Jan 2027TuesdayPlanned

Episode 9: Custody Court Crossfire

Coercive Control vs. Alienation Claims

When a parent raises abuse in a custody case and the other parent answers with a claim of alienation, what happens? Two major studies give opposite answers.

Episode
9 of 10
Running time
18:02
Sources
23, listed below
A spiral-bound child custody evaluation on a courtroom table
Coming Jan 19The video will play here. Nothing loads from YouTube until you press play. The picture is an AI-generated illustration, not from the records.

What this episode covers

This episode explains why, what a survey of custody evaluators found, what Utah, Colorado and Arizona changed in 2026, and what three appellate opinions show about evidence.

Law checked

12–13Nov 2026

Federal and state law were both checked. Kayden's Law, California's Piqui's Law and Washington's definition: Nov 12, 2026. Colorado HB26-1309, Arizona HB 2995 and Utah HB 303: Nov 13, 2026. Laws change; check the current status in your state.

About the cases

All cases come from published court opinions in the public record. We do not name the parties in narration. In X.K. v. M.C. the facts are one party's account and have not been tested at a full hearing. The Canadian study is a comparison point, not a US estimate.

Updates since recording

None so far.

Sources, in on-air order

23 sources. Each has its own link you can copy, for example episode-9.html#S-194.

  1. S-190

    Meier, U.S. child custody outcomes in cases involving parental alienation and abuse allegations: what do the data show?, Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law 42(1), 92-105 (2020): (full text read at

    Peer-reviewed study · United States

  2. S-192

    Harman & Lorandos, Allegations of family violence in court: How parental alienation affects judicial outcomes, Psychology, Public Policy, and Law 27(2), 184-208 (2021; online 2020)

    Peer-reviewed study · United States

  3. S-193

    Meier, Dickson, O'Sullivan & Rosen, Brief Rebuttal of Harman/Lorandos Paper (Jan. 21, 2021); and The Trouble with Harman and Lorandos' Parental Alienation Allegations in Family Court Study (2020), Journal of Family Trauma, Child Custody & Child Development 19(3-4), 295-317 (2022): (reprinted in Parental Alienation and Family Reunification, Routledge, 2023

    Researchers' rebuttal (not peer-reviewed) · United States

  4. S-194

    Harman, Giancarlo, Lorandos & Ludmer, Gender and child custody outcomes across 16 years of judicial decisions regarding abuse and parental alienation, Children and Youth Services Review 155, 107187 (2023)

    Peer-reviewed study · Canada

  5. S-195

    Saunders, Faller & Tolman, Child Custody Evaluators' Beliefs About Domestic Abuse Allegations, final report to the National Institute of Justice (2011), NCJ 238891

    Government-funded research report · United States

  6. S-196

    Trocmé & Bala, False allegations of abuse and neglect when parents separate, Child Abuse & Neglect 29(12) (2005)

    Peer-reviewed study · Canada

  7. S-206

    Knott, Trocmé & Bala, False allegations of abuse and neglect, CECW Information Sheet #13E (2004)

    Research report · Canada

  8. S-197

    AFCC and NCJFCJ, Joint Statement on Parent-Child Contact Problems (2022)

    Professional bodies' joint statement · United States

  9. S-198

    UN Special Rapporteur on violence against women and girls, its causes and consequences, Custody, violence against women and violence against children, A/HRC/53/36 (Apr. 13, 2023)

    United Nations report · International

  10. S-199

    Harman, Kruk & Hines, Parental alienating behaviors: An unacknowledged form of family violence, Psychological Bulletin 144(12) (2018)

    Peer-reviewed study · United States

  11. S-142

    Colorado HB26-1309 (approved May 27, 2026)

    Enacted law (act or session law) · Colorado

    Shown in the video as S-200

  12. S-201

    Arizona HB 2995, Laws 2026, ch. 263, the Alec and Lydia Act (approved June 22, 2026); KJZZ, Arizona Legislature passes Alec and Lydia Act (June 15, 2026)

    Enacted law (act or session law) · Arizona

  13. S-143

    Utah HB 303 (2026), Utah Code § 81-9-101(2)

    Enacted law (act or session law) · Utah

    Shown in the video as S-202

  14. S-203

    Johnston-Rossi v. Rossi (2023) 88 Cal.App.5th 1081 (Cal. Ct. App., 2d Dist., Div. 8, No. B318522)

    Published appellate opinion · California

  15. S-204

    X.K. v. M.C., Cal. Ct. App., 1st Dist., Div. 4, No. A170020 (June 25, 2025), certified for publication

    Published appellate opinion · California

  16. S-205

    In re Marriage of Humphries, 2024 COA 92 (Colo. Ct. App., No. 22CA1327, Aug. 15, 2024)

    Published appellate opinion · Colorado

  17. S-047

    34 U.S.C. § 10446(k), Keeping Children Safe From Family Violence Act ("Kayden's Law"), Violence Against Women Act Reauthorization Act of 2022, Pub. L. 117-103, div. W, title XV

    Federal statute · United States

  18. S-085

    California SB 331, Piqui's Law: Keeping Children Safe from Family Violence Act, Stats. 2023, ch. 865 (approved Oct. 13, 2023), adding Fam. Code § 3193 and amending Gov. Code § 68555

    Enacted law (act or session law) · California

  19. S-088

    In re Marriage of A.M. and R.Y. (Cal. Ct. App., 4th Dist., Div. 1, No. D084344, filed Apr. 30, 2025; certified for publication)

    Published appellate opinion · California

  20. S-007

    California SB 1141 (2020) summary

    Enacted law (act or session law) · California

  21. S-017

    Rev. Code Wash. § 7.105.010(4) (last amended Laws 2024, ch. 298, § 9)

    Statute · Washington

  22. S-048

    BWJP (Battered Women's Justice Project), The 2022 Reauthorization of the Violence Against Women Act: Title 15, What We Know (& What We Don't) (Dec 2023)

    Advocacy organization resource · United States

  23. S-001

    Stuart, Redefining Domestic Abuse: Coercive Control, ABA Family Law Quarterly (2025)

    Legal scholarship · United States

Background reading for this episode

Read while this episode was researched, and not cited in the video.

  1. S-191

    Meier, J.S., Dickson, S., O'Sullivan, C., Rosen, L. & Hayes, J. (2019). Child Custody Outcomes in Cases Involving Parental Alienation and Abuse Allegations. Final summary overview to the National Institute of Justice. NCJ 304419.

    Research report · United States