Need help? National Domestic Violence Hotline 1-800-799-7233, or text START to 88788. In an emergency, call 911.Hotline 1-800-799-7233, or text START to 88788. Emergency: 911.

Understanding Coercive Control

Sources library

160 entries: 159 sources and the State Law Atlas. Every source the ten episodes cite, with its link, the kind of source it is, and what the series took from it. Episode pages list the same sources in on-air order.

Showing 160 of 160 entries

  1. S-001

    Stuart, Redefining Domestic Abuse: Coercive Control, ABA Family Law Quarterly (2025)

    Legal scholarship · United States · 2025

    Summarizes Stark's (2007) framing of abuse as an ongoing pattern that strips liberty, and US legal responses.

  2. S-002

    Johnson, A Typology of Domestic Violence (2008)

    Scholarly book · 2008

    Distinguishes intimate terrorism, situational couple violence and violent resistance.

  3. S-003

    Hamberger, Larsen & Lehrner (2017), summary

    Peer-reviewed study (read through a summary) · 2017

    Proposes three facets: intentional/goal-directed behavior, negative perception by the victim, credible threat.

  4. S-004

    S.M.T. v. S.A. (N.J. App. Div. Feb. 10, 2026)

    Appellate court opinion · New Jersey · 2026

    First published NJ appellate opinion applying the 2024 coercive control factor; findings required.

  5. S-005

    In re Marriage of Nadkarni (2009) 173 Cal.App.4th 1483

    Published appellate opinion · California · 2009

    'Disturbing the peace' covers conduct that destroys mental or emotional calm.

  6. S-006

    K.L. v. R.H. (Cal. Ct. App. 2021), No. G059109

    Appellate court opinion · California · 2021

    Mutual orders are the exception; weigh both parties' conduct together.

  7. S-007

    California SB 1141 (2020) summary

    Enacted law (act or session law) · California · 2020

    Adds coercive control to the DVPA's 'disturbing the peace'; effective Jan 1, 2021.

  8. S-008

    New Jersey A1475 / P.L.2023, c.230

    Enacted law (act or session law) · New Jersey · 2024

    Courts must consider coercive control when deciding a final restraining order.

  9. S-009

    Leemis et al., The National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey: 2016/2017 Report on Intimate Partner Violence, CDC (2022), Tables 5 and 6

    Government survey · United States · 2022

    Lifetime coercive control and entrapment by an intimate partner: 46.2% of women (57.6M), 42.8% of men (50.5M). Counts anyone reporting at least one listed behavior.

  10. S-010

    Campbell et al., Risk Factors for Femicide in Abusive Relationships: Results From a Multisite Case Control Study, American Journal of Public Health 93(7), 2003

    Peer-reviewed study · United States · 2003

    Highly controlling abuser: adjusted OR 2.90; controlling abuser plus separation after living together: adjusted OR 8.98 (falls to 4.07 when threats and stalking added)

  11. S-011

    National Domestic Violence Hotline, Warning Signs of Abuse

    Advocacy organization resource · United States

    Lists 12 warning signs (isolation, jealousy, control of decisions and money, shaming, threats to kids or pets, intimidation); 'even one or two' is a red flag.

    Series background

  12. S-012

    Freed et al., "A Stalker's Paradise": How Intimate Partner Abusers Exploit Technology, CHI 2018

    Peer-reviewed study · United States · 2018

    89 participants (39 survivors, 50 professionals) at five NYC Family Justice Centers. Tech abuse is mostly simple: ownership of devices/accounts, known or coerced passwords, harmful messages, exposure of private info. Abuser as 'UI-bound adversary' (authenticated insider). Covers family plans, shared accounts, location services and intimate-image threats; does not mention doorbell or home cameras.

    More on this source

    Notes that safety steps (such as removing spyware) can cut off the abuser's access 'in ways that trigger more severe violence'.

  13. S-013

    Adams, Sullivan, Bybee & Greeson, Development of the Scale of Economic Abuse, Violence Against Women 14(5), 2008

    Peer-reviewed study · United States · 2008

    Economic abuse has two distinct dimensions, economic control and economic exploitation; both predict economic hardship. Sample: 103 women.

  14. S-014

    Hatley v. Southard (Cal. Ct. App. Aug. 1, 2023, certified for publication Aug. 16, 2023), No. E080000

    Published appellate opinion · California · 2023

    Reversed DVRO denial: treating financial control, control of transport and phone, and isolation as 'just evidence of marital problems was error'; abuse under the DVPA is not limited to violence.

  15. S-015

    Toles v. Toles (Wash. Ct. App. Div. I, Mar. 16, 2026, unpublished), No. 87615-5-I

    Unpublished appellate opinion (not binding precedent) · Washington · 2026

    Reversed a DVPO a minor obtained against her stepfather on coercive control; the trial court 'failed to sufficiently consider the protective purpose and effect' of his actions and the good-faith protective-action exclusion in RCW 7.105.010(4)(b). Trial court had found insufficient evidence of assault and made no statutory finding of stalking or harassment.

  16. S-016

    Nan N. v. Rex R. (Mass. App. Ct. Mar. 20, 2026), No. 25-P-524

    Published appellate opinion · Massachusetts · 2026

    Affirmed 209A abuse finding on fear of imminent serious physical harm; did not reach coercive control; notes the coercive control standard is a lower threshold; vacated the part of the order running beyond one year.

  17. S-017

    Rev. Code Wash. § 7.105.010(4) (last amended Laws 2024, ch. 298, § 9)

    Statute · Washington · 2024

    Defines coercive control with examples (intimidation incl. tech and identity documents; isolation; deprivation/financial exploitation; monitoring; abusive litigation; psychological aggression); context from a similarly situated person; excludes good-faith protective actions.

  18. S-018

    Massachusetts, An Act to Prevent Abuse and Exploitation (2024), in effect Sept 18, 2024

    Enacted law (act or session law) · Massachusetts · 2024

    Coercive control within 'abuse': pattern intended to threaten, intimidate, harass, isolate, control, coerce or compel compliance, incl. monitoring activities, communications, movements, finances, by technological means.

  19. S-019

    California SB 50 (2025), connected devices

    Enacted law (act or session law) · California · 2026

    Clarifies disturbing the peace and coercive control can be carried out through internet-connected devices; adds device protection requests (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22948.30 et seq.). Effective Jan 1, 2026.

  20. S-020

    California AB 2534 (Stats. 2026, ch. 950), effective Jan 1, 2027

    Enacted law (act or session law) · California · 2026

    Effective Jan 1, 2027: adds interfering with, threatening, or attempting to prevent a party or witness from participating in court proceedings to the coercive control examples, and treats forced-marriage conduct as disturbing the peace.

  21. S-021

    California Penal Code § 836(c)(3) (dominant aggressor definition, quoted in K.L. v. R.H.)

    Statute · California

    Defines the dominant aggressor as 'the most significant, rather than the first, aggressor'; quoted in K.L. v. R.H.

  22. S-022

    G.P. v. S.P., Mass. Supreme Judicial Court, No. SJC-13947 (pending; constitutional challenge to the coercive control provision)

    Pending appeal (court filings and notices) · Massachusetts · 2026

    Issues before the SJC: whether posting social media videos critical of the plaintiff was 'coercive control' under G.L. c. 209A § 1(d), and whether that provision is unconstitutionally vague and overbroad. Amicus briefs solicited. No decision found as of Nov 11, 2026.

  23. S-023

    V.B. v. B.W.R.T., Mass. App. Ct., No. 25-P-1086 (July 24, 2026) (unpublished)

    Unpublished appellate opinion (not binding precedent) · Massachusetts · 2026

    Vacated a 209A extension order based on coercive control: vague, conclusory testimony about a threat to share private information did not give the judge objective evidence that met the statute. Notes the pending SJC case; expresses no view on constitutionality.

  24. S-025

    Glass et al., Non-fatal Strangulation Is an Important Risk Factor for Homicide of Women, Journal of Emergency Medicine 35(3), 2008

    Peer-reviewed study · United States · 2008

    Prior non-fatal strangulation reported for 10% of abused controls, 45% of attempted homicide victims and 43% of homicide victims (n = 506 cases, 427 controls). OR 6.70 (3.91 to 11.49) for attempted homicide, 7.48 (4.53 to 12.35) for completed homicide. Strangulation 'frequently leaves little in the way of observable injury'. Proxy respondents and survivors interviewed.

  25. S-026

    Campbell et al., Assessing Risk Factors for Intimate Partner Homicide, NIJ Journal No. 250 (Nov 2003), NCJ 196547

    Government-funded research report · United States · 2003

    Danger Assessment items and unadjusted odds ratios among murdered versus abused women: weapon 20.2, threat to kill 14.9, tried to choke 9.9, violently and constantly jealous 9.2, gun in the house 6.1, controls most or all daily activities 5.1. 83% of women killed scored 4 or higher, 'but so did almost 40 percent of the women who were not killed'; use 'as a guide in the process rather than as a precise actuarial tool'.

    More on this source

    Almost half the murdered women did not recognize their risk. 70 to 80% of intimate partner homicides were preceded by the man's physical abuse of the woman.

  26. S-027

    Monckton-Smith, Intimate Partner Femicide: Using Foucauldian Analysis to Track an Eight Stage Progression to Homicide, Violence Against Women 26(11), 2020

    Peer-reviewed study · United Kingdom · 2020

    372 UK intimate partner femicides (2012 to 2015) reviewed from published media and homicide reviews, plus 25 cases studied in depth. Eight stages: pre-relationship, early relationship, relationship, trigger, escalation, change in thinking, planning, homicide. Controlling patterns in every one of the 25 case studies; trigger usually withdrawal of commitment or separation.

  27. S-028

    Myhill & Hohl, The 'Golden Thread': Coercive Control and Risk Assessment for Domestic Violence, Journal of Interpersonal Violence 34(21-22), 2019

    Peer-reviewed study · United Kingdom · 2019

    Random sample of 488 police DASH risk forms from one force in the south of England (2011/12). Threats, controlling behavior, sexual coercion, isolation and fear had the highest loadings; injury in the current incident was 'not associated consistently' with the pattern or with separation.

  28. S-029

    Ratcliffe (Price City Police Department), Investigative Report on the Aug. 12, 2021 Petito-Laundrie Incident, with City of Moab statement (released Jan 12, 2022)

    Independent official review · Utah · 2022

    Officers made 'several unintentional mistakes': no citation or arrest as Utah law required, no statement from the 911 caller, no question about prior domestic violence, incident classed as a mental health crisis.

    More on this source

    The reviewer found it very likely that the woman was 'a long-term victim of domestic violence, whether that be physically, mentally, and/or emotionally', described locking her out of the van as done 'in an attempt to control her movements', and called grabbing her face 'extremely personal, violent, and controlling'. On whether the outcome would have changed: 'Nobody knows and nobody will ever know the answer to that question.'

  29. S-030

    Utah Code § 77-36-2.1 (lethality assessments), added by SB 117, Laws of Utah 2023, ch. 447, effective May 3, 2023; current version effective May 7, 2025

    Statute · Utah · 2025

    Officer responding to an allegation of domestic violence against an intimate partner must complete a lethality assessment: 12 questions, including jealousy or control of daily activities, separation after living together, and following or spying. Referral to an advocate if yes to any of questions (a) to (d), or yes to at least four of (e) to (k), or on the officer's judgment after the open question. Results go with the probable cause statement and incident report and to the Department of Public Safety.

  30. S-031

    Florida Statutes § 741.29 (2026), as amended by ch. 2024-70 (SB 1224), effective July 1, 2024, and ch. 2025-89

    Statute · Florida · 2024

    Officer investigating alleged domestic violence against an intimate partner must administer a lethality assessment 'regardless of whether an arrest is made'. Same 12 questions and referral rule as Utah. Statewide form due Jan 1, 2025; all officers trained by Oct 1, 2026; agency certification by Nov 1, 2026; compliance report due Jan 1, 2027. Completed forms are confidential.

  31. S-032

    Messing, Campbell, Wilson, Brown, Patchell & Shall, Police Departments' Use of the Lethality Assessment Program: A Quasi-Experimental Evaluation, final report to the National Institute of Justice, Doc. No. 247456 (July 2014)

    Government-funded research report · Oklahoma · 2014

    Seven Oklahoma police jurisdictions. Intervention group (screened high danger and spoke with a hotline advocate) reported a significant decrease in the frequency and severity of violence at a median of 7 months and more protective strategies than a high-violence comparison group. Lethality Screen: sensitivity 92 to 93%, negative predictive value 93 to 96%, specificity 21%, positive predictive value 13 to 21%.

  32. S-033

    Graham, Sahay, Rizo, Messing & Macy, The Validity and Reliability of Available Intimate Partner Homicide and Reassault Risk Assessment Tools: A Systematic Review, Trauma, Violence, & Abuse 22(1), 2021

    Peer-reviewed systematic review · 2021

    43 studies of 18 tools in eight countries. 'The majority of studies were administered or coded by researchers rather than administered in real-world settings'; research on feasibility in practice settings is lacking. 26 studies focused on male perpetrators.

  33. S-034

    Maine Domestic Abuse Homicide Review Panel, 15th Biennial Report (December 2025), Office of the Maine Attorney General

    Official fatality review · Maine · 2025

    17 cases from 2021 to 2024 (17 perpetrators, 20 victims); 9 intimate partner homicides. In those 9: stalking before the homicide 78% (7 of 9); physical abuse before 78% (7 of 9); emotional or verbal abuse used as coercive and controlling tactics 89% (8 of 9); isolation 56% (5 of 9); prior threats to kill 33% (3 of 9); known prior strangulation 11% (1 of 9).

    More on this source

    'Short of physical violence, people are reluctant to consider coercive and controlling abusive behavior as potentially lethal, particularly if the abusive person has not done something recognized as a crime.' 'Perpetrators who have not previously used physical violence as a tactic may still be capable of committing homicides.'

  34. S-035

    Sullivan v. Schuyler, 31 Wn. App. 2d 791, 556 P.3d 157 (Wash. Ct. App. Div. II, July 2, 2024; ordered published Sept. 17, 2024), No. 57794-1-II

    Published appellate opinion · Washington · 2024

    Affirmed denial of a motion to terminate a 2017 domestic violence protection order (expiring 2099) that rested on post-breakup stalking: repeated calls and messages, GPS tracking, impersonation. The commissioner found a substantial change in circumstances but that the acts were too severe to terminate the order. 'Severity' under RCW 7.105.500(6) 'encompasses both physical and nonphysical actions'.

  35. S-036

    Rev. Code Wash. § 7.105.500(6) (declining to terminate a protection order because of the severity of the acts), last amended Laws 2025, ch. 122, § 4

    Statute · Washington · 2025

    'Regardless of whether there is a substantial change in circumstances, the court may decline to terminate a protection order if it finds that the acts of domestic violence, sexual assault, commercial sexual exploitation, stalking, unlawful harassment, and other harmful acts that resulted in the issuance of the protection order were of such severity that the order should not be terminated.'

  36. S-037

    Gruver, FBI: Laundrie admitted killing Gabby Petito in notebook, Associated Press (Jan 21, 2022)

    News report · Wyoming · 2022

    The FBI announced on Jan 21, 2022 that a notebook found near the man's body contained his admission, and that its investigation identified no one else as directly involved. Coroner: death by blunt-force injuries to the head and neck with manual strangulation, about three weeks before she was found on Sept 19, 2021.

  37. S-038

    News reports on the wrongful death suit against the City of Moab: Ashcraft, Deseret News / KSL (Jan 30, 2026); Smith & Randazzo, WWSB (Aug 27, 2026)

    News report · Utah · 2026

    Suit dismissed in November 2024; appeal set for argument at the Utah Supreme Court on March 4, 2026, later postponed when the case was joined with another; no new date as of Aug 27, 2026. The central issue is governmental immunity. The family's attorney says the family was instrumental in passing SB 117. She was 22.

  38. S-039

    Utah Statewide Information and Analysis Center, Intelligence Note 250331-1240334, Utah Domestic Violence Related Homicides July 2023 to January 2025 (released Mar 31, 2025)

    State data note · Utah · 2025

    17,649 lethality assessments submitted between July 2023 and January 2025. 52 domestic violence related homicides, 30 intimate partner related. Nine assessments were associated with a homicide; all nine had a yes on the jealousy or control question (weapon 5, threat to kill 5, belief 3, choke 5, gun 5, separation 6, follow or spy 4). Three of the nine were completed after the homicide; two involved people not directly connected.

    More on this source

    Only four of the 30 intimate partner homicides had an assessment involving the suspect and victim beforehand.

  39. S-040

    Katz, Beyond the Physical Incident Model: How Children Living with Domestic Violence are Harmed By and Resist Regimes of Coercive Control, Child Abuse Review 25(1), 46-59 (2016; online 2015)

    Peer-reviewed study · 2016

    Fathers'/father-figures' coercive control often prevented children from spending time with their mothers and grandparents, visiting other children's houses and doing extra-curricular activities, leaving them in 'isolated, disempowering and constrained worlds'; children also resist. Responsibility belongs with the perpetrator, not the victimized parent.

    More on this source

    A child's words quoted in the episode: 'me and Mum would watch a movie and have some time together, which he wouldn't let us do when he was there' (a 12-year-old, under a pseudonym). 'All of the children were directly emotionally abused.'

  40. S-041

    Callaghan, Alexander, Sixsmith & Fellin, Beyond "Witnessing": Children's Experiences of Coercive Control in Domestic Violence and Abuse, Journal of Interpersonal Violence 33(10), 1551-1581 (2018; online 2015)

    Peer-reviewed study · 2018

    Children 'can be reasonably described as victims of abusive control'; themes of abusive control, constraint, and children as agents with strategies for managing it.

  41. S-042

    Jouriles & McDonald, Intimate Partner Violence, Coercive Control, and Child Adjustment Problems, Journal of Interpersonal Violence (Feb 2015)

    Peer-reviewed study · United States · 2015

    Coercive control related positively to mothers' and children's reports of child externalizing and internalizing problems after accounting for frequency of physical IPV, psychological abuse and mothers' education.

  42. S-043

    Beeble, Bybee & Sullivan, Abusive Men's Use of Children to Control Their Partners and Ex-Partners, European Psychologist 12(1), 54-61 (2007)

    Peer-reviewed study · United States · 2007

    88% of 156 women said their assailant had used the children against them: to stay in their lives (70%), keep track of them (69%), harass (58%), intimidate (58%), turn the children against them (47%), persuade the children she should take him back (45%), frighten (44%). More use by biological fathers and by abusers with court-ordered visitation.

  43. S-044

    Sullivan, Sprecher, Guerrero, Fernandez & Simmons, The Use of Children as a Tactic of Intimate Partner Violence and its Impact on Survivors' Mental Health and Well-being Over Time, Journal of Family Violence 39, 153-163 (2024; online Dec. 14, 2022)

    Peer-reviewed study · United States · 2022

    92% of mothers reported their children had been used against them in the six months before the first interview; 66% at 6 months, 61% at 12, 53% at 18 and 51% at 24 months. After controlling for other abuse, use of the children predicted higher anxiety and PTSD symptoms and lower quality of life over time, but not depression. Uses the 7-item Use of the Children Scale from Beeble et al. (2007).

  44. S-045

    Katz, Nikupeteri & Laitinen, When Coercive Control Continues to Harm Children: Post-Separation Fathering, Stalking and Domestic Violence, Child Abuse Review 29(4), 310-324 (2020)

    Peer-reviewed study · 2020

    Three themes after separation: dangerous fathering, 'admirable' fathering (caring, concerned, indulgent, vulnerable-victim), and omnipresent fathering; 'admirable' fathering can be performed for professionals and obscure the control.

  45. S-046

    Hamby, Finkelhor, Turner & Ormrod, Children's Exposure to Intimate Partner Violence and Other Family Violence, OJJDP Juvenile Justice Bulletin, NCJ 232272 (Oct 2011)

    Government-funded research report · United States · 2011

    NatSCEV (2008): 6.6% of children exposed to physical IPV between parents in the past year, 17.9% lifetime; 11% past-year and 25.6% lifetime exposure to any family violence; about half of exposed youth yelled at parents to stop or tried to get away, 23.6% called for help. Items cover assaults, threats and property destruction, not coercive control.

  46. S-047

    34 U.S.C. § 10446(k), Keeping Children Safe From Family Violence Act ("Kayden's Law"), Violence Against Women Act Reauthorization Act of 2022, Pub. L. 117-103, div. W, title XV

    Federal statute · United States · 2022

    STOP grant increase of up to 10% (one fiscal year at a time, four at most) for states with laws on expert evidence, past-abuse evidence, no removal from a bonded protective parent solely to improve the other relationship, limits on reunification treatment, and 20 hours initial / 15 hours every 5 years of training for judges and custody personnel; training topics include 'coercive control'. $5 million authorized per year, FY 2023-2027. Private custody cases only, not child protection cases.

  47. S-048

    BWJP (Battered Women's Justice Project), The 2022 Reauthorization of the Violence Against Women Act: Title 15, What We Know (& What We Don't) (Dec 2023)

    Advocacy organization resource · United States · 2023

    Title 15 is an incentive, not a mandate. Concerns: the expert-evidence rule has no threshold for an allegation and applies when either parent alleges abuse; 'clinical experience' is undefined; mandatory consideration of past abuse applies even to defensive acts; the reunification limits could restrict repair when the rejected parent is the survivor. Notes Pennsylvania's Kayden's Law has different provisions.

  48. S-049

    Colorado HB23-1178, Session Laws 2023, ch. 266 (approved May 25, 2023), adding C.R.S. § 14-10-127.5

    Enacted law (act or session law) · Colorado · 2023

    Written 'in compliance with' the federal Keeping Children Safe From Family Violence Act; expert standards; training that includes coercive control for custody professionals; directs the judicial branch to apply for the federal grant increase.

  49. S-050

    Pennsylvania Act 8 of 2024 (Senate Bill 55 of 2023, Printer's No. 1169), known as Kayden's Law; approved April 15, 2024, in effect Aug. 13, 2024. Also the Philadelphia Legal Assistance summary (Aug 2024) and the sponsor's page

    Enacted law (act or session law) · Pennsylvania · 2024

    Act text: findings say abuse tactics 'are not necessarily physical or illegal' and can include 'controlling behaviors, monitoring, litigation abuse and threats to seek or demands for custody or joint custody to pressure the partner to return or punish the partner for leaving.' First custody factor is now 'Which party is more likely to ensure the safety of the child' (23 Pa.C.S. § 5328(a)(1)); frequent contact with the other party counts only 'if contact is consistent with the safety needs of the child' ((a)(2.3)).

    More on this source

    A finding of ongoing risk of abuse creates a rebuttable presumption of supervised custody (§ 5323(e.1)). The court training program is permissive ('may develop') and its topic list does not name coercive control (42 Pa.C.S. § 1908). The act's text does not use the name 'Kayden'; the sponsor's memo and summaries do. Secondary sources say the law is named for a seven-year-old killed by her father during a court-ordered unsupervised visit, three months after the custody order.

  50. S-051

    Nicholson v. Scoppetta, 3 N.Y.3d 357 (N.Y. Oct. 26, 2004)

    Published appellate opinion · New York · 2004

    A child's exposure to the abuse of a parent is not by itself neglect; the agency must show actual or imminent impairment and failure to exercise a minimum degree of care ('not maximum, not best, not ideal', 3 N.Y.3d at 370); courts weigh 'risks attendant to leaving,' 'to staying' and 'to seeking assistance through government channels' (at 371); 'a blanket presumption favoring removal was never intended' (at 378).

  51. S-052

    In re Marriage of Brubaker & Strum (2021) 73 Cal.App.5th 525 (Cal. Ct. App., 2d Dist., Div. 7, No. B307887, filed Dec. 10, 2021, certified for publication Jan. 3, 2022)

    Published appellate opinion · California · 2021

    Renewal of a restraining order does not require new abuse; the question is reasonable fear of future abuse on all the facts; a custody-trial finding of compliance does not bar earlier evidence. Facts include a co-parenting app used to 'scold, admonish, [and] reprimand' and 'using the children as a pretext to further harass.'

  52. S-053

    New York Kyra's Law (S5998 / A6194, 2026): status reports. Lewis, Here's where key legislation stands with Gov. Kathy Hochul, City & State New York (Nov 9, 2026); Vielkind, Why NY judges oppose bill to make safety top priority in child custody battles, New York Public News Network / WAMC (Sept 5, 2026)

    News report · New York · 2026

    Shown in the videos also as S-230

    Passed both houses unanimously; awaiting the governor as of Nov 9, 2026 (deadline end of year). Would put child safety first in custody decisions and require judges to review abuse allegations before custody orders. The Family Court Judges Association asked for a veto: erodes discretion, 'overwhelming increase' in hearings.

  53. S-054

    Kelly & Johnson, Differentiation Among Types of Intimate Partner Violence: Research Update and Implications for Interventions, Family Court Review 46(3), 476-499 (2008)

    Peer-reviewed study · United States · 2008

    Four patterns (coercive controlling violence, violent resistance, situational couple violence, separation-instigated violence); 'reliable differentiation should provide the basis for determining what safeguards are necessary and what types of parenting plans are appropriate'; calls for improved screening.

  54. S-055

    Kudon et al., NISVS 2023/2024 Intimate Partner Violence Data Brief, CDC (February 2026), Tables 7 and 9

    Government survey · United States · 2026

    Lifetime coercive control by an intimate partner: 27.2% of women (95% CI 25.7-28.7; about 34.8M) and 19.5% of men (17.8-21.2; about 23.7M), Tables 7 and 9. Seven behaviors listed (own money, family/friends, keeping track, threats of harm, threats of self-harm, decisions, destroying something important). Data Sept 2023 to Sept 2024; 15,609 adults; weighted response rate 16.5%. Page 1 cautions against comparing with earlier NISVS years.

  55. S-056

    CDC, NISVS 2023/2024 Methodology Report and NISVS FAQ

    Government report · United States · 2026

    2023/2024 used an address-based sampling frame and push-to-web design with a telephone alternative; earlier years were random-digit-dial telephone surveys. Items changed from 'how many people ever' to yes/no. 'Given these changes, comparing 2023/2024 findings to NISVS findings from previous data years is not advised.' Only stalking requires more than one occasion.

  56. S-057

    Dutton, Goodman & Schmidt, Development and Validation of a Coercive Control Measure for Intimate Partner Violence: Final Technical Report (NIJ, 2005)

    Government-funded research report · United States · 2005

    Coercion measure tested with n=757 (448 females, 302 males; 139 victims only, 39 perpetrators only, 245 both, 334 neither) recruited in Washington, DC (493) and Boston (264). Defines coercion as 'the credible threat of delivering a negative consequence for noncompliance'.

    More on this source

    Scales: Demands (9 subscales), Coercion (31 items), Surveillance (13 items), Response. 'Higher coercion was related to greater number of demands and surveillance tactics'; associated with PTSD, depression, threat appraisal and fear; after controlling for other IPV the link held for PTSD, threat appraisal and fear 'but not for depression'; findings held for males and females separately.

  57. S-058

    Hardesty, Crossman, Haselschwerdt, Raffaelli, Ogolsky & Johnson, Toward a Standard Approach to Operationalizing Coercive Control and Classifying Violence Types, Journal of Marriage and Family (2015)

    Peer-reviewed study · United States · 2015

    Approaches to assessing coercive control 'have been inconsistent.' Divorcing mothers (N=190, two projects, recruited from divorce filings, 80% White) rated seven control tactics on the PMWI Dominance-Isolation subscale. Scored by frequency, 8 of 190 (4.2%) changed groups between hierarchical and k-means clustering; scored as a count of tactics, 41 (21.5%) did, and 60.5% landed in the high-control group, 'a proportion that is unlikely in a general sample.'

    More on this source

    With a count 'the number of high controllers may be inflated ... by including partners who used a range of different behaviors at a very low frequency.' Results 'provide substantial support for operationalizing coercive control by the frequency, rather than number, of tactics used by a partner.' Suggests a cutoff of 19 (of 35). Limits: 'generalizable only to women with children ending their marriages'; cutoff needs replication; small nonviolent-control group.

  58. S-059

    Myhill, Measuring Coercive Control: What Can We Learn From National Population Surveys?, Violence Against Women 21(3) (2015)

    Peer-reviewed study · United Kingdom · 2015

    Secondary analysis of the 2008/2009 Crime Survey for England and Wales self-completion module (n=3,544 with one abusive relationship since age 16). Coercive control = partner did both: 'Repeatedly belittled you to the extent that you felt worthless' and 'frightened you, by threatening to hurt you or someone close to you' (p. 362). 24% of the abuse was classed as coercive control: 30% (n=791) of abuse reported by women, 6% (n=52) by men (p. 364).

    More on this source

    Coercive control was linked to more severe and frequent violence, injury, emotional harm (odds about 2.7), time off work (about 2x), help-seeking and abuse continuing after separation (33% vs 17%). Abstract: 'the prevalence of situational violence is fairly symmetrical' while 'coercive controlling abuse is highly gendered'; calls for measures covering more controlling behaviors 'as well as the meaning and impact of abuse.' Limits (pp. 364, 371): the method 'is not perfect'; it 'almost certainly categorized a number of relationships as coercive control that in fact contained only situational violence'; findings 'should not be generalized to the population of victims in England and Wales.'

  59. S-060

    Walby & Towers, Untangling the concept of coercive control: Theorizing domestic violent crime, Criminology & Criminal Justice 18(1) (2018)

    Peer-reviewed study · United Kingdom · 2018

    Argues 'measuring coercive control is a challenge that has not yet been satisfactorily met'; proposes 'domestic violent crime' as the lead concept: count all violent crimes and their harms, count repeats separately, do not cap series. Reports that most domestic violent crime is repeat victimization concentrated on a small group of mostly female victims.

  60. S-061

    Office for National Statistics (UK), Developing a measure of controlling or coercive behaviour (Apr. 18, 2019)

    Official statistics · United Kingdom · 2019

    Split-sample test from April 2017 of new survey questions with 'repeatedly or continuously' wording and impact items. Year ending March 2018, partner or ex-partner: 1.7% (new) vs 3.0% (existing non-physical abuse questions); women 2.2% vs men 1.2% on the new measure. Concluded the questions 'were not fit for purpose in their current form'; removed April 2019. Noted impacts 'could disproportionately apply to female experiences.'

  61. S-062

    Office for National Statistics (UK), Domestic abuse prevalence and trends, England and Wales: year ending March 2025 (Nov. 26, 2025); and Redevelopment of domestic abuse statistics: research update May 2025

    Official statistics · United Kingdom · 2025

    New survey questions in use from year ending March 2024; estimates not comparable with the old questions. The new questions 'do not fully align with the offence definition and therefore cannot be used to calculate an estimate' of controlling or coercive behaviour. Police recorded 49,557 such offences in year ending March 2025; rises attributed to improved police recognition. Offence introduced by the Serious Crime Act 2015.

  62. S-063

    US Preventive Services Task Force, Intimate Partner Violence and Caregiver Abuse of Older or Vulnerable Adults: Screening, Final Recommendation Statement (June 24, 2025)

    Independent federal panel recommendation · United States · 2025

    Grade B: clinicians screen for IPV in women of reproductive age, including pregnant and postpartum. Names HARK (Humiliation, Afraid, Rape, Kick), HITS (Hurt, Insult, Threaten, Scream) and WAST; accuracy review also covers an 'Afraid/Controlled/Threatened/Slapped or physically hurt' screen. 'The review identified no eligible screening or intervention studies for IPV in men.' I statement for caregiver abuse of older or vulnerable adults.

  63. S-064

    Spence et al., Screening for coercive control with refugee women accessing settlement services, BMC Public Health (2025)

    Peer-reviewed study · Australia · 2025

    SAHAR study: caseworkers in four settlement services asked 312 women the four-item ACTS questions (how often in the last 12 months a partner made them Afraid, Controlled, Threatened, or Slapped/physically hurt; score of 1 or more indicates abuse). 90 (29%) screened positive (results section: of 309 screened); control was the most frequent form (78 of 90, 88%); 34 answered yes to all four. The team first planned to use HITS ('four items on frequency by a partner of hitting (physically hurting), insults, threats, or screaming/ swearing') and chose ACTS to ask about control.

  64. S-065

    G.G. v. G.S., Cal. Ct. App., 2d Dist., Div. 4, No. B331994 (May 28, 2024), certified for publication

    Published appellate opinion · California · 2024

    Reversed denial of a DVRO renewal. Original order rested on stalking (listening devices; 'appellant counted 70 incidents in which respondent appeared at or in front of her home at night', cameras). Trial court asked about 'significant, say, physical harm'. Held: 'The law does not permit courts to make a distinction between physical and non-physical abuse when issuing DVROs'; renewal does not require ongoing abuse. Remanded for a new hearing.

  65. S-066

    Kehlani K. v. Tripp T., Mass. App. Ct., No. 25-P-960 (Oct. 22, 2026)

    Published appellate opinion · Massachusetts · 2026

    Affirmed a one-year 209A order where the plaintiff 'consistently limited her allegations of abuse to abuse by coercive control' (fn. 8). 'In this case, we interpret and apply this statutory language for the first time.' Facts: driveway 'on a near daily basis,' sometimes blocking her car in; 'circling' the house on a doorbell camera; entering the house 'even after the plaintiff had changed the locks'; one admitted entry 'through an unlocked window'; photographing her calendar; soccer game; school; New York movie theater; vacation rental; hotel; 'for months and months.'

    More on this source

    Held: pattern has its plain meaning, '[a] mode of behavior or series of acts that are recognizably consistent' (Black's Law Dictionary); monitoring her activities and movements met subsection (a)(iii); intent to coerce or compel compliance (to drop the divorce) inferred from conduct; evidence showed 'a reduced sense of physical safety or autonomy'; autonomy means the ability 'to make significant decisions unfettered by concerns that doing so will expose that person to abuse'; 'reasonably' modifies both fear of physical harm and the reduced sense of safety or autonomy. Left open: any minimum number of acts (fn. 12); orders based solely on speech (fn. 14); whether fear of physical harm was also shown (fn. 15). Defendant did not challenge constitutionality; court noted G.P. v. S.P., SJC-13947, pending (fn. 14).

  66. S-068

    Cal. Fam. Code § 6345(a) (renewal of a domestic violence restraining order), as quoted in G.G. v. G.S. (S-065)

    Statute · California

    An order may be renewed 'without a showing of further abuse since the issuance of the original order'; the test is whether a reasonable person, in the petitioner's circumstances, would fear repetition of the abuse if the order expired.

  67. S-085

    California SB 331, Piqui's Law: Keeping Children Safe from Family Violence Act, Stats. 2023, ch. 865 (approved Oct. 13, 2023), adding Fam. Code § 3193 and amending Gov. Code § 68555

    Enacted law (act or session law) · California · 2023

    Fam. Code § 3193: a court 'shall not order family reunification treatments, programs, or services' that as a condition of participation require or result in a no-contact order; an overnight, out-of-state or multiday stay; a transfer of physical or legal custody; private youth transporters using force or threats; or threats, undue coercion, verbal abuse or isolation.

    More on this source

    Gov. Code § 68555: the Judicial Council 'shall establish' training for judicial officers and court-employed custody professionals; the listed topics include '(D) Coercive control' and that domestic violence 'can occur without a party seeking or obtaining a restraining order, without a substantiated child protective services finding, and without other documented evidence of abuse.' Annual report from Jan. 1, 2025. Findings repeat 'approximately 1 in 15 children' and state the aim of moving California toward eligibility for the federal grant increase. The text names the law 'Piqui's Law' and gives no fuller name.

  68. S-086

    Oklahoma Domestic Violence Fatality Review Board, 2025 Annual Report (reviews 2024 deaths)

    Official fatality review · Oklahoma · 2025

    2024: 77 domestic violence fatality events, 87 victims. 16 children were killed by family or household members; 7 of the 16 in murder-suicides, and 4 of those 7 in murder-suicides tied to partner violence: 'these children were killed in the context of their father trying to "get back at" their mother by killing the child.' 48 children witnessed or were in direct proximity to 24 fatalities, so children were present at 31.2% of fatal events.

  69. S-087

    Washington State Coalition Against Domestic Violence, Domestic Violence Fatality Review Recommendations: Family Law (from the Washington fatality review reports, including Up to Us, 2010)

    Advocacy organization resource · Washington · 2010

    Recommends that family law attorneys 'Routinely screen clients for domestic violence and coercive, controlling behavior by the other party' and 'Draft parenting plan provisions that minimize opportunities for abusers to intimidate and control the victim' (Up to Us, 2010, p. 36), with training for guardians ad litem and evaluators.

  70. S-088

    In re Marriage of A.M. and R.Y. (Cal. Ct. App., 4th Dist., Div. 1, No. D084344, filed Apr. 30, 2025; certified for publication)

    Published appellate opinion · California · 2025

    A sworn showing of yelling in front of the child, unannounced visits, barrages of texts, pressure over money and custody, sexual pressure during the marriage and one forceful grab was enough for a prima facie case that the respondent disturbed the petitioner's peace (Fam. Code § 6320(a), (c), which 'includes, but is not limited to, coercive control').

    More on this source

    'the court may not deny ex parte relief at the DVTRO stage solely because otherwise sufficient allegations of abuse may have arisen in the context of a family law dispute' (p. 17). Limits: the court recognized such petitions 'are sometimes used for tactical purposes in family law cases' (p. 17); a judge keeps discretion to deny a temporary order if it is not needed for protection before the hearing, with stated reasons (pp. 15-16); remanded without ordering protection.

  71. S-089

    ABC7 Los Angeles, report on the signing of Piqui's Law (Oct. 14, 2023)

    News report · California · 2023

    The law is named for a five-year-old South Pasadena boy who was killed by his father in 2017 during a custody dispute; his mother urged the governor to sign it.

  72. S-100

    Woods v. Horton (2008) 167 Cal.App.4th 658, Cal. Ct. App., 3d Dist., No. C056072 (Oct. 14, 2008)

    Published appellate opinion · California · 2008

    Four men and the daughter of one sued over state laws funding domestic violence programs for women only (Health & Safety Code § 124250 and Penal Code § 13823.15). The trial court denied relief, finding women more often victims and more severely injured. Reversed in part: 'equal protection is not concerned with numbers'; both statutes reformed to fund services 'regardless of gender'.

    More on this source

    Identical services are not required; 'it may be appropriate to provide more and different services to battered women and their children'. The court did not decide what happened on the lead plaintiff's call to a program. Challenge to a prison program for women rejected.

  73. S-101

    J.R. v. N.K., 232 Conn. App. 434 (May 6, 2025), No. AC 46564

    Published appellate opinion · Connecticut · 2025

    The examples of coercive control in Conn. Gen. Stat. § 46b-1(b)(4) 'do not constitute an exhaustive or exclusive list' (slip p. 12); the trial judge had considered only the examples. Applying the wider definition itself, the court still found no prima facie case: 'even if the defendant's actions while the parties were living together constituted coercive control ..., any coercive control contemplated by the statute had ended by the time the plaintiff filed' (pp. 16-17).

    More on this source

    The emails had 'a legitimate purpose' (pp. 20-21). The applicant's unpreserved equal protection claim (that he was treated differently as an immigrant, a minority and a member of the LGBTQ community than 'heterosexual or female victims') failed: the record was 'devoid of any evidence' of selective treatment (p. 26). Disposition: 'Improper form of judgment; reversed; judgment directed' (dismissal to be entered under Practice Book § 15-8, failure to make out a prima facie case, instead of § 14-3).

  74. S-103

    Chen et al., NISVS 2016/2017 Report on Victimization by Sexual Identity, CDC (October 2023), Tables 27 and 30

    Government survey · United States · 2023

    Lifetime coercive control by an intimate partner: heterosexual women 45.1%, lesbian women 60.6%, bisexual women 69.7%; heterosexual men 42.5%, gay men 48.6%, bisexual men 50.6% (Tables 27 and 30). No estimates for transgender respondents (too few).

  75. S-104

    Johnson, Conflict and Control: Gender Symmetry and Asymmetry in Domestic Violence, Violence Against Women 12(11) (2006)

    Peer-reviewed study · United States · 2006

    Presents evidence 'that situational couple violence dominates in general surveys, intimate terrorism and violent resistance dominate in agency samples, and this is the source of differences across studies with respect to the gender symmetry of partner violence' (p. 1003). 'In heterosexual relationships, intimate terrorism is perpetrated almost exclusively by men' (p. 1003). Table 1 (p. 1010): intimate terrorism 97% husbands, 3% wives (97 cases).

    More on this source

    Table 2 (p. 1011): intimate terrorism is 11% of husbands' violence in the general sample, 68% in the court sample, 79% in the shelter sample.

  76. S-105

    Johnson, Leone & Xu, Intimate Terrorism and Situational Couple Violence in General Surveys: Ex-Spouses Required, Violence Against Women 20(2): 186-207 (2014)

    Peer-reviewed study · United States · 2014

    Abstract reports that reports about former spouses in a national survey show intimate terrorism to be largely male-perpetrated.

  77. S-106

    Douglas & Hines, The Helpseeking Experiences of Men Who Sustain Intimate Partner Violence: An Overlooked Population and Implications for Practice, Journal of Family Violence 26(6) (2011)

    Peer-reviewed study · United States · 2011

    302 men who sought help after violence by a female partner. Of the 67 who called a domestic violence hotline, 63.9% said they were told 'We only help women' and 32.2% were referred to a batterers' program or told they were the batterer (Table 3). The article's text and Table 3 disagree on the figure for domestic violence agencies (49.9% against 78.3%), so only the hotline column is used. The text and the table agree on both hotline figures. Data collected Dec 2007 to Jan 2009.

  78. S-107

    Hines & Douglas, A Closer Look at Men Who Sustain Intimate Terrorism by Women, Partner Abuse 1(3): 286-313 (2010)

    Peer-reviewed study · United States · 2010

    Same help-seeking sample of 302 men.

  79. S-108

    Bates, Graham-Kevan & Archer, Testing predictions from the male control theory of men's partner violence, Aggressive Behavior 40(1) (2014)

    Peer-reviewed study · United Kingdom · 2014

    In 1,104 students reporting on their own behavior, 'there were no substantial sex differences in controlling behavior, which significantly predicted physical aggression in both sexes'; 'women were more likely than men to be classed as "intimate terrorists"' (both on p. 42).

  80. S-109

    Barlow, Johnson, Walklate & Humphreys, Putting Coercive Control into Practice: Problems and Possibilities, British Journal of Criminology 60(1) (2020)

    Peer-reviewed study · United Kingdom · 2020

    From one English police force's use of the coercive control offence: findings 'also support the view that the current gender-neutral version of the legislation requires revision' (p. 160). Conclusion: 'First, the current version of the legislation requires revision. In particular, our data supports the observations of Stark and Hester (2019), highlighting concerns with the gender-neutral nature of the offence in England and Wales' (p. 175).

    More on this source

    Also reports missed chances to use the offence in almost 9 of 10 intimate partner assault cases reviewed (p. 174).

  81. S-110

    Woulfe & Goodman, Identity Abuse as a Tactic of Violence in LGBTQ Communities: Initial Validation of the Identity Abuse Measure, Journal of Interpersonal Violence 36(5-6) (2021; online 2018)

    Peer-reviewed study · United States · 2018

    Among 734 sexual minority adults in an online survey (53.1% women, 27.4% men, 19.3% transgender or gender nonconforming), 40.1% reported identity abuse by a partner in adulthood (16.8% in the past year).

  82. S-111

    James et al., The Report of the 2015 U.S. Transgender Survey, National Center for Transgender Equality (2016), executive summary

    Survey research by an advocacy organization · United States · 2016

    27,715 respondents. 54% 'experienced some form of intimate partner violence, including acts involving coercive control and physical harm'.

  83. S-112

    Hirschel, Buzawa, Pattavina, Faggiani & Reuland, Explaining the Prevalence, Context, and Consequences of Dual Arrest in Intimate Partner Cases, report to the National Institute of Justice (2007), NCJ 218355

    Government-funded research report · United States · 2007

    Year 2000 NIBRS data: 577,862 police records, 2,819 departments, 19 states. 'The overall dual arrest rate for all intimate partner violence cases was 1.9%, 26.1% of the female same sex cases, and 27.3% of the male same sex cases'. Officers may be 'unable, or unwilling, to assign primary responsibility to one of the parties involved in a same sex incident'.

  84. S-113

    34 U.S.C. § 12291(a)(12) and (b)(13) (Violence Against Women Act definitions and grant conditions)

    Federal statute · United States · 2022

    Shown in the videos also as S-135

    Domestic violence for victim services 'includes ... a pattern of any other coercive behavior committed, enabled, or solicited to gain or maintain power and control over a victim'. No person may be excluded from a funded program on the basis of sex, gender identity or sexual orientation, among others; sex-specific programming is allowed when 'necessary to the essential operation of a program' if 'comparable services' are provided.

  85. S-114

    Rhode Island Coalition Against Domestic Violence v. Blanche, D.R.I., No. 25-cv-279 (orders of Apr. 17 and Sept. 29, 2026)

    Federal trial court orders · United States · 2026

    State coalitions challenged conditions the Office on Violence Against Women attached to grants in 2025, including one on 'gender ideology'. On Sept. 29, 2026 the court found them arbitrary and capricious and set them aside. The order does not discuss § 12291(b)(13). No appeal found; none ruled out.

  86. S-115

    Cal. Penal Code § 13823.15 (Comprehensive Statewide Domestic Violence Program)

    Statute · California · 2026

    The funding definition now reads in gender-neutral terms ('intimate partners', 'that person') while keeping 'a pattern of assaultive, coercive, and controlling behaviors'.

  87. S-116

    Washington State Administrative Office of the Courts, DV Manual for Judges (2015), Appendix D, Domestic Violence in Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, and Queer Relationships

    Judicial bench guide · Washington · 2015

    'The threat of "outing" is an effective tool to control and coerce a survivor.' Advises looking at who is 'further isolated and controlled' when both partners claim to be the victim.

  88. S-117

    Battered Women's Justice Project, National Defense Center for Criminalized Survivors

    Advocacy organization resource · United States · 2026

    Technical assistance for survivors charged with crimes and for their defense teams and advocates.

  89. S-118

    Salmon v. Salmon (2022) 85 Cal.App.5th 1047, Cal. Ct. App., 4th Dist., Div. 2, No. E075748

    Published appellate opinion · California · 2022

    Mainly a physical violence case that does not turn on coercive control. Background reading; not cited in the episode.

  90. S-119

    Connecticut law check of Nov 13, 2026: OLR bill analysis of Conn. HB 5438 (2026); Conn. Public Act 26-92

    Legislative record · Connecticut · 2026

    Connecticut HB 5438 (2026) concerns evidence at restraining order hearings and does not change the coercive control definition; its final status was not confirmed, and Public Act 26-92 contains no 'coercive' text.

  91. S-120

    New York City Anti-Violence Project

    Advocacy organization resource · New York · 2026

    A community resource listing describes its hotline as offering support 'to LGBTQ & HIV-affected survivors of any type of violence'.

  92. S-121

    NW Network of Bisexual, Trans, Lesbian & Gay Survivors of Abuse, archive of writing, resources and tools

    Advocacy organization resource · Washington · 2026

    The site is an archive: 'Direct Advocacy and Technical Assistance services are not offered via this site', and the original website 'is no longer accessible and may not return'.

  93. S-122

    45 C.F.R. § 1370.5 (Family Violence Prevention and Services Act programs, nondiscrimination)

    Federal regulation · United States · 2017

    Grantees must provide 'comparable services to victims regardless of actual or perceived sex, including gender identity', including 'access to services for all victims, including male victims'. Sex-segregated or sex-specific programming only where 'essential to the normal or safe operation of the program'. No exclusion 'on the ground of actual or perceived sexual orientation'.

  94. S-123

    McCord v. Smith (2020) 51 Cal.App.5th 358, Cal. Ct. App., 4th Dist., Div. 3, No. G057614

    Published appellate opinion · California · 2020

    Each asked for a domestic violence restraining order against the other. His temporary order was granted Jan. 2, 2019; her request of Jan. 8 'was denied pending a hearing because (1) a TRO had already been issued protecting' him and (2) he had no notice (p. 5). On Feb. 8 he blocked her car in her driveway; 'Because [he] was the protected party under the existing TRO, the responding officer filed an informational report but conducted no further investigation' (p. 5).

    More on this source

    After a hearing with two of her friends and her daughter as witnesses, the trial court found it did 'not believe [he] is fearful of' her, that he 'tried to exercise some dominion or control over' her, that texting a photo of her nursing license ('Is this yours?') was 'a threat', and that his continued contact was 'classic stalking behavior' (p. 6). Affirmed: courts weigh 'the totality of the circumstances' (p. 9, Fam. Code § 6301(c)); relies on In re Marriage of Nadkarni.

  95. S-124

    Stark & Hester, Coercive Control: Update and Review, Violence Against Women 25(1) (2019)

    Peer-reviewed study · United States · 2019

    'This work reinforces our belief that coercive control by a male partner is the most common and most devastating context for women's help-seeking because of abuse' (p. 91). Abstract: 'Coercive control is not a type of violence'; 'important differences in coercive control dynamics distinguish male homosexual from lesbian couples' (p. 81).

    More on this source

    Also: 'Coercion and control may also be used by same-sex partners'; one study of 184 gay men and lesbians found 'men and women were equally likely to engage in coercive control' (p. 91).

  96. S-130

    Cruse v. C.C., 58 N.E.3d 974 (Ind. Ct. App. Aug. 19, 2016), No. 41A01-1512-PO-2345; the court's own PDF as archived

    Published appellate opinion · Indiana · 2016

    Protective order limiting an ex-husband's contact with his ex-wife reversed 2 to 1. Majority: no evidence he 'attempted to, threatened to, or did cause any acts of physical harm' or 'placed C.C. in fear of physical harm'; stalking not shown because 'She was not frightened, she merely "preferred" that Cruse not be around when she was with the children' (para. 8). Dissent: 'Cruse's conduct is symptomatic of controlling behavior, which is a form of domestic violence' (para. 22).

    More on this source

    No appellee's brief was filed, so the prima facie error standard applied. Also: she testified she felt 'intimidated' at the graduation (para. 5); the majority: 'Although she did comment that at one point she felt intimidated, most of her concerns were based upon the way other people were reacting to Cruse' (para. 8). She had no lawyer at trial (dissent, para. 21).

  97. S-131

    Ind. Code § 34-6-2.1-50 (definition of domestic or family violence); Indiana courts' note on the 2019 harassment law (H.E.A. 1607)

    Statute · Indiana · 2026

    The definition lists attempting, threatening or causing physical harm; placing a family or household member in fear of physical harm; forced sexual activity; and abusing or killing an animal to threaten, intimidate, coerce, harass or terrorize; plus stalking and sex offenses for protective orders. It does not mention coercive control. Since July 1, 2019, 'a person may file a petition for an order for protection against a person who commits repeated acts of harassment.'

    More on this source

    SB 201 (2026) was introduced Jan 8, 2026 and died in committee.

  98. S-132

    Montelauro v. Lutkus, 2025 IL App (2d) 240369 (May 20, 2025)

    Published appellate opinion · Illinois · 2025

    Plenary order of protection affirmed. Former dating partners (under six months). After the breakup: 10 voicemails in about a week; messages from unfamiliar numbers after she blocked him; a recorded confrontation at her home in which he grabbed her wrist and did not release it; later texts in Dec 2022 and Feb/Mar 2023; in Feb 2024 he sent, from an account under a different name, a nude photo she had shared during the relationship.

    More on this source

    Trial court found harassment and interference with personal liberty; the photo was 'clearly meant to harass' and sent to get her to respond (para. 40). Both findings upheld (paras. 45-62).

  99. S-133

    Illinois Domestic Violence Act of 1986, 750 ILCS 60/103

    Statute · Illinois · 2026

    'Interference with personal liberty' means 'committing or threatening physical abuse, harassment, intimidation or willful deprivation so as to compel another to engage in conduct from which she or he has a right to abstain or to refrain from conduct in which she or he has a right to engage.' 'Abuse' includes harassment and interference with personal liberty. Harassment is presumed from listed conduct such as creating a disturbance at the petitioner's work or school and repeated surveillance.

    More on this source

    The section does not use the words coercive control. Source line: P.A. 96-1551, eff. 7-1-11; 97-1150, eff. 1-25-13.

  100. S-134

    Illinois HB 4659 (104th General Assembly), status

    Bill (pending when checked) · Illinois · 2026

    Shown in the videos also as S-225

    Status page read Nov 13, 2026: first reading and referred to Rules Feb 3, 2026; assigned to the Judiciary-Criminal Committee Mar 4, 2026; co-sponsor added Mar 12, 2026; no vote shown. Not passed.

  101. S-136

    18 U.S.C. § 2265 (full faith and credit given to protection orders) and § 2266(5)

    Federal statute · United States · 2024

    A protection order issued by a court with jurisdiction, after reasonable notice and opportunity to be heard, 'shall be accorded full faith and credit by the court of another State, Indian tribe, or territory ... and enforced ... as if it were the order of the enforcing State or tribe.'

    More on this source

    Under (d)(2) it is enforceable 'notwithstanding failure to comply with any requirement that the order be registered or filed in the enforcing State.' Section 2266(5) defines protection order to include any order 'for the purpose of preventing violent or threatening acts or harassment against, sexual violence, or contact or communication with or physical proximity to, another person.'

  102. S-137

    Conn. Gen. Stat. § 46b-1(b)

    Statute · Connecticut · 2021

    Domestic violence includes '(4) coercive control of such family or household member, which is a pattern of behavior that in purpose or effect unreasonably interferes with a person's free will and personal liberty,' with six listed examples (isolating; depriving of basic necessities; controlling, regulating or monitoring movements, communications, daily behavior, finances, economic resources or access to services; compelling by force, threat or intimidation; cruelty to animals; forced sex acts or sexual threats).

    More on this source

    History note: subsection (b) added effective June 28, 2021.

  103. S-138

    Haw. Rev. Stat. § 586-1; § 709-906; Act 192 of 2026 (HB 1959)

    Statute · Hawaii · 2026

    Shown in the videos also as S-160

    Section 586-1 defines coercive control as 'a pattern of threatening, humiliating, or intimidating actions, which may include assaults, or other abuse that is used to harm, punish, or frighten an individual,' with eight examples. Section 709-906(6): 'It shall be a petty misdemeanor for a person to ... exercise coercive control, as defined in section 586-1, over a family or household member.' The criminal provision is part of a pilot.

    More on this source

    Act 192 changes the repeal date from June 30, 2026 to June 30, 2031; its text says it takes effect June 29, 2026; the governor's message says it was signed July 7, 2026.

  104. S-139

    15 V.S.A. § 1101

    Statute · Vermont · 2024

    'Coercive controlling behavior' means 'a pattern of behavior that in purpose or effect unreasonably interferes with a person's free will and personal liberty,' with six listed examples that track Connecticut's.

  105. S-140

    New Hampshire Laws 2026, ch. 230 (HB 1522), amending RSA 173-B:1; statute page

    Enacted law (act or session law) · New Hampshire · 2026

    Abuse still means one of the listed acts 'where such conduct is determined to constitute a credible present threat to the petitioner's safety.' New sentence: 'In its analysis of abuse, the court may consider the presence of coercive control as defined in paragraph II-a.' II-a: 'a pattern of conduct that includes, but is not limited to, a manifestation of the defendant's intent to threaten, intimidate, harass, isolate, coerce, control, or compel compliance, which causes the petitioner to reasonably fear for his or her physical safety,' with examples including some single acts. The only new listed act of abuse is nonconsensual dissemination of private sexual images.

  106. S-141

    Ariz. Rev. Stat. § 25-403.03

    Statute · Arizona · 2026

    For legal decision-making and parenting time, domestic violence means an act under § 13-3601(A) or 'coercive control,' defined as 'a pattern of violent, threatening, coercive or emotionally abusive conduct by one parent against the other, without consent or justification,' with fifteen listed examples (including litigation abuse and surveillance technology). A finding creates a mandatory rebuttable presumption against awarding legal decision-making or parenting time to that parent. Self-defense is excluded.

  107. S-142

    Colorado HB26-1309 (approved May 27, 2026)

    Enacted law (act or session law) · Colorado · 2026

    Shown in the videos also as S-200

    Coercive control is defined in custody law as 'a pattern of threatening, humiliating, or intimidating actions, including assaults or other abuse, that is used to harm, punish, or frighten an individual,' with a list of examples; the act moves and expands the definition and lists coercive control and economic abuse within domestic violence for custody. The custody statute already defined coercive control before 2026.

  108. S-143

    Utah HB 303 (2026), Utah Code § 81-9-101(2)

    Enacted law (act or session law) · Utah · 2026

    Shown in the videos also as S-202

    'Coercive control' means 'an individual's pattern of behavior that, intentionally or in effect, unreasonably interferes with another individual's ability to make or act on independent decisions,' with nine listed patterns; it 'does not include reasonable and appropriate parental conduct undertaken in the care of a minor child.' Courts may consider evidence of coercive control in custody and parent-time decisions. The coercive control sections took effect on the governor's approval; the rest on May 6, 2026.

  109. S-144

    BWJP, Coercive Control Codification: A Brief Guide for Advocates and Coalitions (November 2021)

    Advocacy organization resource · United States · 2021

    Shown in the videos also as S-174

    'Most jurisdictions' criminal, civil protection, and family legal system responses fall short, especially when violence isn't physical and recent.' On protective orders: 'some survivors and advocates are concerned that coercive control will prove to be a Trojan horse: that abusive partners will manipulate the system and claim coercive control as a basis for receiving orders against survivors,' heightened because 'most survivors represent themselves.'

    More on this source

    Statutory language 'must be crafted so that it is not overbroad.' On custody: some fear the language 'will be used against survivors'; others say 'even the most carefully crafted statutory language will fail to provide the needed clarity.' On criminal law: concern that criminalization will lead to the arrest and incarceration of survivors, particularly survivors of color.

  110. S-145

    BWJP, Coercive Control Codification Matrix (updated through the 2023 legislative sessions; file dated 2024)

    Advocacy organization resource · United States · 2024

    State-by-state matrix of statutes that use coercive control or related wording. A starting list; it predates the 2024 to 2026 laws (Vermont, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Arizona, Colorado 2026, Utah, New Hampshire).

  111. S-146

    Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, amicus announcements, September 2025 to August 2026 (G.P. v. S.P., SJC-13947)

    Pending appeal (court filings and notices) · Massachusetts · 2026

    Questions: 'Whether the plaintiff was subjected to abuse, specifically, "coercive control" as defined in G. L. c. 209A, § 1 (d), where the defendant publicly posted numerous videos on social media that were critical of the plaintiff'; and 'Whether the "coercive control" provision is vague and overbroad in violation of the First and Fifth Amendments to the United States Constitution and cognate provisions of the Massachusetts Constitution.' No decision found in a search on Nov 13, 2026.

  112. S-147

    New York S8633A / A9551 (2025-2026): would define coercive control in the Family Court Act, allow orders of protection on a finding, and require courts to weigh it in custody

    Bill (pending when checked) · New York · 2026

    Last action Apr 23, 2026: amended (print 8633A) and recommitted to the Senate Children and Families Committee. Not passed; the session's bills die Dec 31, 2026.

  113. S-148

    D.A. v. A.C., 235 Conn. App. 111 (Conn. App. Ct., officially released Sept. 16, 2025), AC 47507

    Published appellate opinion · Connecticut · 2025

    Restraining order under § 46b-15 affirmed. The trial court made no findings on which statutory ground (threat, stalking, coercive control) supported the order, and the defendant did not challenge the stalking and coercive control grounds, so the Appellate Court did not decide them. The court quoted the coercive control definition and said it did not condone the trial court's 'toxic' custody language.

  114. S-149

    Arkansas Act 1068 of 2021 (Ark. Code § 9-15-219)

    Enacted law (act or session law) · Arkansas · 2021

    '"Course of control" means a pattern of behavior that in purpose or effect unreasonably interferes with the free will and personal liberty of a person,' with four examples (isolating; depriving of basic necessities; controlling, regulating or monitoring movements, communications, daily behavior, finances; compelling by intimidation, force or threats including immigration status). '"Disturbing the peace" includes without limitation course of control.'

    More on this source

    'A court may enter an ex parte order enjoining a party from engaging in course of control or disturbing the peace.' The words 'coercive control' are not used. HB 1829 (2025), which would have moved the definition into 'domestic abuse' (§ 9-15-103) and repealed § 9-15-219, passed the House Apr 3, 2025 and was withdrawn Apr 15, 2025.

  115. S-150

    Oklahoma Statutes, Title 43, § 109

    Statute · Oklahoma · 2026

    For custody disputes, '"domestic violence" means the threat of the infliction of physical injury, any act of physical harm or the creation of a reasonable fear thereof, or the intentional infliction of emotional distress by a parent or a present or former member of the household of the child, against the child or another member of the household including coercive control by a parent involving physical, sexual, psychological, emotional, economic or financial abuse' (§ 109(I)(2)(b)). The term is not defined.

    More on this source

    A finding of domestic violence 'raises a rebuttable presumption' that custody with the perpetrator is detrimental to the child (§ 109(I)(1)). History note: last amended by Laws 2024, c. 24, eff. Nov. 1, 2024.

  116. S-151

    Mississippi HB 1386 (2020), Advocate Confidentiality Law (Miss. Code § 93-21-125)

    Enacted law (act or session law) · Mississippi · 2020

    In the law making communications between victims and advocates confidential: 'The term "domestic violence" also includes any pattern of behavior or coercive control resulting in physical, emotional or psychological harm to a victim' committed by a spouse, former spouse, household member, relative, co-parent or dating partner. The term is not defined.

  117. S-152

    Maine 19-A M.R.S. § 4102

    Statute · Maine · 2025

    Abuse includes '(C) Compelling a person by force, threat of force, coercion or intimidation: (1) To engage in conduct from which the person has a right or privilege to abstain; or (2) To abstain from conduct in which the person has a right to engage.' The words 'coercive control' do not appear in the definition, though the 2025 act's title uses them.

  118. S-162

    Hawaii Act 238, Session Laws 2021 (HB 566, HD 1, SD 1), with Governor's Message 1366 (July 7, 2021)

    Enacted law (act or session law) · Hawaii · 2021

    Added 'exercise coercive control' to the petty misdemeanor offense in § 709-906. The governor's message says the bill 'became law without my signature as ACT 238, Session Laws of Hawaii 2021, on July 6, 2021.'

  119. S-163

    Testimony on HB 566, HD 1, Hawaii Senate Committee on Judiciary (Mar. 19, 2021)

    Legislative record · Hawaii · 2021

    Hawaii State Coalition Against Domestic Violence, in support: 'We should no longer rely on a victim to endure physical abuse to get justice.' Office of the Public Defender 'strongly opposes': 'This measure will criminalize arguments or disagreements in relationships and marriages', and 'we are concerned about misuse of this measure by the actual abusers who may easily twist and manipulate the definition of "coercive control" for their own use to further subjugate a partner.'

    More on this source

    Department of the Attorney General 'opposes this bill': 'The definition of "coercive control" is vague and overbroad'; 'it is not suited for criminal prosecution'; much of the conduct was already covered by other crimes. Honolulu Prosecuting Attorney filed concerns. Domestic Violence Action Center, AAUW of Hawaii and Planned Parenthood Votes Northwest and Hawaii supported.

  120. S-165

    The Judiciary, State of Hawaii, Report on Domestic Violence and Increased Offender Accountability, pursuant to Act 19, SLH 2020 (December 2025), Judiciary Comm. No. 8

    Government report · Hawaii · 2025

    From January 2021 through June 2025, 6,778 cases were filed under § 709-906; 1,751 were petty misdemeanors. The petty misdemeanor category covers offensive touching as well as coercive control. The report gives no figure for coercive control cases.

  121. S-166

    The Marshall Project, How 'Coercive Control' Is Expanding Domestic Abuse Laws in Several States, by Alysia Santo (June 28, 2025)

    News report · United States · 2025

    Reports that Hawaii prosecutors filed 736 petty misdemeanor domestic violence cases from July 2021 to June 2023 and that 'it's not clear how many of those were specifically coercive control cases.' Quotes law professor Courtney Cross: 'The people who have the hardest time staking out their claim to victimhood are the ones most likely to have some of these laws used against them.' On the South Carolina case: Mica, 30, died April 27, 2024, her death ruled a suicide; she 'had recently filed for legal separation from her husband'; her family said she was a victim of coercive control; police said she had spoken to them numerous times about damage to her car and tracking devices; her husband 'has denied abusing Mica, and his lawyer has called the allegations "unfounded rumors and false accusations"'; 'Mica's family believes these laws could have saved her life.' Also reports the NCJFCJ adding coercive control to its model code in 2022 and bills in Maine, Kentucky and Washington (the series did not verify these).

  122. S-167

    New York Senate Bill S4079 / Assembly Bill A679 (2025-2026), establishing the crime of coercive control

    Bill · New York · 2025

    Would make coercive control a class E felony. In the Senate Codes committee; last action Jan 7, 2026. Not law. Bills die Dec 31, 2026 if not passed.

  123. S-168

    South Carolina S. 702 (2025-2026), Criminal Coercive Control; WRDW, S.C. senator to reintroduce 'Mica's Law' targeting coercive control (June 30, 2026)

    Bill · South Carolina · 2026

    S. 702 would have made coercive control a criminal domestic violence offense; the bill page shows no action after Jan 14, 2026. WRDW reports that supporters call it Mica's Law, that it failed to advance in 2026, and that the sponsor plans to reintroduce it in January 2027. The bill's text does not name the woman it is known for.

  124. S-169

    UK Home Office, Review of the Controlling or Coercive Behaviour Offence (2021)

    Government report · United Kingdom · 2021

    Police-recorded offences rose from 4,246 (2016/17) to 24,856 (2019/20). The share ending in a charge fell from 11% to 6% (2017/18 to 2018/19), while charge rates fell for many crimes. 85% of offences were closed for evidential difficulties (2018/19). The review said it was 'not yet possible to draw definitive conclusions' about the offence's effects.

  125. S-170

    Office for National Statistics (UK), Domestic abuse and the criminal justice system, England and Wales: November 2025, with appendix tables 16 and 17

    Official statistics · United Kingdom · 2025

    Table 17 (Ministry of Justice data, calendar year 2024): 853 offenders convicted with controlling or coercive behaviour as the principal offence; 832 male, 9 female (the rest not recorded); average custodial sentence 25.3 months. Table 16: 5,374 offences reached a first hearing at magistrates' courts.

  126. S-171

    NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research, Coercive Control Monitoring Report, quarterly report December 2025 (published March 2026)

    Official statistics · Australia · 2026

    From July 1, 2024 (when the offence began) to December 2025: 473 coercive control incidents recorded by police; 22 coercive control charges laid; 1 proven in court; 17 pending.

  127. S-172

    Department of Justice Canada, Protecting Victims Act (Bill C-16) backgrounder

    Government summary of a bill · Canada · 2026

    Bill C-16 received Royal Assent on June 18, 2026. It creates an offence of coercive control of an intimate partner; that offence was not yet in force when the page was read.

  128. S-173

    National Domestic Violence Hotline, Law Enforcement Experience Report (2022), report led by Leigh Goodmark

    Survey research by an advocacy organization · United States · 2022

    2021 survey of 1,502 people who contacted the Hotline. Of the 1,225 who had called the police: 39% felt less safe afterward, 20% felt safer; 25% were threatened with arrest; 12% were arrested; 71% would have preferred other resources had they been available; 62% would call again. 93% of respondents were women and 62% white.

  129. S-175

    Sheley, Criminalizing Coercive Control Within the Limits of Due Process, 70 Duke Law Journal 1321 (2021)

    Legal scholarship · United States · 2021

    Argues that a statute drafted like the UK's 'would raise insurmountable due process problems under the U.S. Constitution,' and proposes a model offense: a coercive pattern 'over a substantial period of time with the intent to deprive another person of their autonomy to make decisions and engage in conduct to which they otherwise have the right' (p. 1387). 'The purpose here is not to advocate directly for immediate legislation' (p. 1327).

    More on this source

    Criminalization 'should not occur in a vacuum, but only against a backdrop of police reform' (p. 1393). 'The fact that a state could create this offense, however, does not of course mean that it should' (p. 1391).

  130. S-176

    Cross, Coercive Control and the Limits of Criminal Law, 56 UC Davis Law Review 195 (2022)

    Legal scholarship · United States · 2022

    Argues that 'criminalizing coercive control will do far more harm than good' and that such laws 'will be coopted by abusive partners and used against survivors' (abstract). Draws on mandatory arrest and no-drop prosecution policies of the 1990s: survivors 'are being arrested individually and along with their abusive partner at significantly higher rates than before mandatory policies were put in place' (p. 239).

    More on this source

    Accusations would need 'almost no corroboration' and 'could thus be easy for abusive partners to levy against their victims' (p. 238). Suggests family court 'may provide a venue that is more able to analyze and respond to claims of coercive control than criminal court' (p. 224).

  131. S-177

    R v Chilvers [2021] EWCA Crim 1311 (Court of Appeal of England and Wales, Criminal Division, Aug. 27, 2021)

    English appellate judgment (not US law) · United Kingdom · 2021

    A jury convicting of controlling or coercive behaviour 'did not have to be unanimous as to which particular kind or kinds of controlling or coercive behaviour they were satisfied had been established' (para 72). Appeal against conviction dismissed (para 73).

  132. S-178

    Counterman v. Colorado, 600 U.S. 66 (2023), No. 22-138 (June 27, 2023)

    US Supreme Court opinion · United States · 2023

    In a true-threats prosecution, the First Amendment requires the State to prove the defendant had 'some subjective understanding' of the threatening nature of the statements; recklessness is enough. Conviction vacated and remanded. The opinion does not mention coercive control.

  133. S-179

    Ireland, Domestic Violence Act 2018, section 39 (offence of coercive control)

    Enacted law (act or session law) · Ireland · 2018

    Ireland has a criminal offence of coercive control of a spouse, civil partner or intimate partner.

  134. S-180

    U.S. Attorney's Office, District of South Carolina, Myrtle Beach Pastor Indicted for Cyberstalking Wife Before Her Death (press release, Dec. 18, 2025)

    Government press release · South Carolina · 2025

    A federal grand jury returned a two-count indictment against a Myrtle Beach pastor 'for cyberstalking and making false statements to federal investigators.' 'The indictment alleges that beginning in November 2022, Miller sent unwanted and harassing communications to his estranged wife until her death on April 27, 2024.'

    More on this source

    Alleged conduct from November 2022 until his estranged wife's death on April 27, 2024: 'posting a nude photo of the victim online without her consent, causing tracking devices to be placed on her vehicle, and in one instance, contacting her over 50 times in a single day'; also interfering with her finances and daily activities and damaging her tires. 'All charges in the indictment are merely accusations and defendants are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty.' The release does not name his wife or say how she died.

  135. S-181

    WPDE, Trial delayed for JP Miller, pastor at center of Netflix docuseries about Mica Miller (Sept. 23, 2026); FITSNews, Mica Miller Timeline (Sept. 1, 2026); Netflix Tudum (Aug. 26, 2026)

    News report · South Carolina · 2026

    He pleaded not guilty at arraignment in Florence on Jan 12, 2026. The trial was moved from the October 2026 term to the January 2027 term (WPDE, Sept 23, 2026) after several earlier continuances. He has not been charged in connection with her death, which North Carolina authorities ruled a suicide. A three-part Netflix series, Death of the Pastor's Wife, was released in 2026. Tudum reports that S. 702 stalled in 2026 and that its sponsor intends to reintroduce it.

  136. S-190

    Meier, U.S. child custody outcomes in cases involving parental alienation and abuse allegations: what do the data show?, Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law 42(1), 92-105 (2020): (full text read at

    Peer-reviewed study · United States · 2020

    NIJ-funded (2014-MU-CX-0859). All electronically published US custody opinions 2005-2014; over 15,000 triaged, 4,338 coded. Mothers' abuse claims credited 41% (789/1946) with no alienation cross-claim (DV 45%, child physical abuse 27%, child sexual abuse 15%); 23% (51/222) with one (CSA 2%, 1/51). Mothers who began with custody lost it 26% (284/1111) without an alienation claim, 50% (81/163) with one, 73% (60/82) when alienation was credited; 13% (63/468) lost custody even when the father's abuse was credited.

    More on this source

    When alienation was credited, mothers and fathers 'lost custody at identical rates (71%)'.

  137. S-191

    Meier, J.S., Dickson, S., O'Sullivan, C., Rosen, L. & Hayes, J. (2019). Child Custody Outcomes in Cases Involving Parental Alienation and Abuse Allegations. Final summary overview to the National Institute of Justice. NCJ 304419.

    Research report · United States · 2019

    Where guardians ad litem or custody evaluators are appointed, unfavorable outcomes for mothers and gender differences increase.

  138. S-192

    Harman & Lorandos, Allegations of family violence in court: How parental alienation affects judicial outcomes, Psychology, Public Policy, and Law 27(2), 184-208 (2021; online 2020)

    Peer-reviewed study · United States · 2021

    'A total of 967 appellate reports in which PA was found or alleged'; 'six pre-registered hypotheses'; 'We failed to find any support for the conclusions made by Meier (2019)'; 'Parents found (versus alleged) to alienate their children, regardless of their gender, had greater odds of losing parenting time, losing custody of their children, and losing their case'; 'the majority of courts carefully weigh allegations of all forms of family violence'.

    More on this source

    Cases released 1984/85 through 2018, chosen newest first, aiming for equal numbers of alienating mothers and fathers; 19 coders blind to hypotheses. A known alienating parent had 2.41 times the odds of losing custody. One hypothesis from Meier was supported: mothers more likely than fathers to lose their appeal ('the meaning of this finding is difficult to interpret'). Limits in its own words: 'most trial-level cases are not appealed'; 'trial-level courts are not required to publish their rulings'. Footnote 5 acknowledges some cases were not first classified correctly; re-run results 'similar... however, the effects were often stronger'. No external funding.

  139. S-193

    Meier, Dickson, O'Sullivan & Rosen, Brief Rebuttal of Harman/Lorandos Paper (Jan. 21, 2021); and The Trouble with Harman and Lorandos' Parental Alienation Allegations in Family Court Study (2020), Journal of Family Trauma, Child Custody & Child Development 19(3-4), 295-317 (2022): (reprinted in Parental Alienation and Family Reunification, Routledge, 2023

    Researchers' rebuttal (not peer-reviewed) · United States · 2021

    Harman and Lorandos collected appellate alienation cases only; their 'search went back 34 years'; they 'did not and could not "test" our study by only collecting alienation cases'. Says the two studies converge on two points: credited alienation outweighs credited abuse for both genders, and mothers' abuse allegations are treated as false more often.

    More on this source

    The 23-page reply (J. Family Trauma, Child Custody & Child Development 19(3-4), 295-317, 2022, doi 10.1080/26904586.2022.2036286) adds: the second study's 'dataset consists solely of alienation cases; they have no abuse cases without alienation claims'; it mixes private custody cases with cases filed by the state; 'nearly 1 in 5 cases (18%, 140/767) in their data were miscoded' and the gender findings do not survive the authors' own corrections; the second study 'produced virtually the same finding' that parents found to be alienating lose custody regardless of gender (p. 95); and on how often abuse allegations are true, false or fabricated, 'Neither study can directly answer these questions' (p. 101).

  140. S-194

    Harman, Giancarlo, Lorandos & Ludmer, Gender and child custody outcomes across 16 years of judicial decisions regarding abuse and parental alienation, Children and Youth Services Review 155, 107187 (2023)

    Peer-reviewed study · Canada · 2023

    500 parental alienation cases drawn from 4,889 Canadian trial decisions. Says legislation, naming Kayden's Law, was based on 'one unreviewed study with identified methodological issues' and rests 'largely on unverifiable and unreplicated research findings'. Cases span 2004 to 2020; only cases where alienation was found; 64.4% of alienating parents were mothers.

    More on this source

    Reports 'mixed support' for its hypotheses: no gender difference in loss of parenting time, but 'alienating mothers were more likely to lose custody and their case than alienating fathers' (small effect). Only 35 of 500 alienated parents had a finding of abuse.

  141. S-195

    Saunders, Faller & Tolman, Child Custody Evaluators' Beliefs About Domestic Abuse Allegations, final report to the National Institute of Justice (2011), NCJ 238891

    Government-funded research report · United States · 2011

    465 custody evaluators (plus 200 judges, 131 legal aid attorneys, 119 private attorneys, 193 DV program workers). In a vignette of 'serious, coercive-controlling domestic violence', '23% of the evaluators said they would explore coercive/controlling behavior'; those evaluators were more likely to believe DV is important in custody decisions, mothers do not make false DV allegations, and victims do not alienate.

    More on this source

    'Favoring the offender over the victim in custody arrangements was significantly related to several beliefs', including that DV victims alienate children and DV allegations are typically false. Evaluators estimated 26% of mothers' and 31% of fathers' DV allegations were false. Unsupervised visitation was the most likely vignette recommendation (47% average likelihood).

  142. S-196

    Trocmé & Bala, False allegations of abuse and neglect when parents separate, Child Abuse & Neglect 29(12) (2005)

    Peer-reviewed study · Canada · 2005

    1998 Canadian Incidence Study; 7,672 investigations in 51 child welfare areas. 'More than one-third of maltreatment investigations are unsubstantiated, but only 4% of all cases are considered to be intentionally fabricated'; 12% where a custody or access dispute has occurred; neglect is the most common intentionally false report; 'anonymous reporters and noncustodial parents (usually fathers) most frequently make intentionally false reports'; 'custodial parents (usually mothers) and children were least likely'.

  143. S-197

    AFCC and NCJFCJ, Joint Statement on Parent-Child Contact Problems (2022)

    Professional bodies' joint statement · United States · 2022

    'There should be no immediate label used for parent-child contact problems as there are multiple factors and dynamics that may account for these issues', including 'a response to a parent's abusive behaviors, the direct or indirect exposure to intimate partner violence, parental alienating behaviors'. Warns against 'gendered and politicized assumptions that either parental alienation or intimate partner violence is the determinative issue'.

  144. S-198

    UN Special Rapporteur on violence against women and girls, its causes and consequences, Custody, violence against women and violence against children, A/HRC/53/36 (Apr. 13, 2023)

    United Nations report · International · 2023

    Refers to 'the discredited and unscientific pseudo-concept of parental alienation'. Recommends that 'States legislate to prohibit the use of parental alienation or related pseudo-concepts in family law cases' and that 'The use of "reunification camps" for children as part of any outcome in legal proceedings be prohibited'.

  145. S-199

    Harman, Kruk & Hines, Parental alienating behaviors: An unacknowledged form of family violence, Psychological Bulletin 144(12) (2018)

    Peer-reviewed study · United States · 2018

    Argues that parental alienating behaviors are a form of family violence that has gone unacknowledged. Concludes that 'causing severe parental alienation is an egregious form of family violence, specifically child abuse and intimate partner violence' (p. 1290). Maps alienating behaviors onto the CDC's categories of partner violence, including coercive control: alienating parents 'use their children as weapons to a great extent when they exercise coercive control' (p. 1281).

    More on this source

    Says claims of abuse 'should be investigated' and claims of alienating behaviors 'should be considered with the same weight and concern' (p. 1290).

  146. S-201

    Arizona HB 2995, Laws 2026, ch. 263, the Alec and Lydia Act (approved June 22, 2026); KJZZ, Arizona Legislature passes Alec and Lydia Act (June 15, 2026)

    Enacted law (act or session law) · Arizona · 2026

    25-403.03(D): 'If the court determines that a parent has committed domestic violence, there is a mandatory rebuttable presumption that an award of legal decision-making or parenting time to that parent is contrary to the child's best interests'; the court may not require proof that the violence was severe or frequent. (C): 'Corroboration from exhibits or witness testimony of another person is not required'. (B): specific written findings.

    More on this source

    Domestic violence includes coercive control and 'does not include' self-defense or defense of another. Coercive control includes isolation, monitoring finances, and 'threatening, initiating or using civil litigation' to force the other parent 'to defend against a legal claim that is false or frivolous'. KJZZ: named for two children murdered by their father in 2024; passed unanimously.

  147. S-203

    Johnston-Rossi v. Rossi (2023) 88 Cal.App.5th 1081 (Cal. Ct. App., 2d Dist., Div. 8, No. B318522)

    Published appellate opinion · California · 2023

    Order sending two teenagers to a four-day reunification program followed by at least 90 days of no contact with their mother reversed: 'Nothing in the record supports the court's finding that this significant disruption to the children's established living arrangement with mother was in their best interest.' The second judge had refused to hear witnesses, treating the issues as 'already resolved' by an earlier order allowing 'a week-long program'.

  148. S-204

    X.K. v. M.C., Cal. Ct. App., 1st Dist., Div. 4, No. A170020 (June 25, 2025), certified for publication

    Published appellate opinion · California · 2025

    Denial of a restraining order reversed where the trial court said the testimony concerned 'custody and visitation issues' that do not 'fall under the definition of what is domestic violence'. Error 'either by applying an erroneous definition of abuse under the DVPA, or by improperly denying the DVRO because the allegations of abuse occurred in the context of a marital dissolution action involving custody and visitation, or both' (p. 10). Allegations matched to Fam. Code 6320(c)(1), (3).

    More on this source

    Relies on In re Marriage of A.M. & R.Y. (2025) 110 Cal.App.5th 1115, 1130.

  149. S-205

    In re Marriage of Humphries, 2024 COA 92 (Colo. Ct. App., No. 22CA1327, Aug. 15, 2024)

    Published appellate opinion · Colorado · 2024

    After a five-day hearing the trial court rejected the mother's abuse claims, found she 'severely alienated' the children, moved decision-making for the younger child to the father and fined her $36,500. Affirmed: admission of alienation expert testimony; rejection of abuse claims as unsupported. Reversed: the decision-making change (must use 14-10-131 and its heightened standard) and the fine.

  150. S-206

    Knott, Trocmé & Bala, False allegations of abuse and neglect, CECW Information Sheet #13E (2004)

    Research report · Canada · 2004

    Of an estimated 135,573 investigations in 1998: 42% substantiated, 23% suspected, '31% were unsubstantiated but reported in good faith', 4% intentionally false. With a custody or access dispute (about 15,000 investigations): 12% intentionally false, against 3% without one; 40% substantiated, 14% suspected.

    More on this source

    'When examining cases involving a custody or access dispute, non-custodial fathers were responsible for 43% of all intentionally false allegations documented in the CIS-1998, and custodial mothers were responsible for 14%.' Overall sources of intentionally false reports: relatives, neighbours, acquaintances 32%; anonymous 22%; non-custodial parents (mostly fathers) 16%; professionals 10%; custodial parents 4%; children 2%. By type: neglect 48%, physical abuse 31%, sexual abuse 14%, emotional abuse 7%.

  151. S-220

    Asbach v. Couto, Wash. Ct. App. Div. II, Nos. 60325-0-II, 60331-4-II, 60335-7-II (Mar. 31, 2026; published by order May 12, 2026)

    Published appellate opinion · Washington · 2026

    A father with a history of violence posted a video addressed to his son calling the mother a narcissist; the trial court found it coercive control (the judge called him "manipulative and on the edge, carefully avoiding criminal prosecution").

    More on this source

    The Court of Appeals agreed the video was coercive control in context, held an order cannot be denied only because the conduct was not recent, and held the orders may prohibit speech that constitutes coercive control but not speech that is not; the ban on posting anything that refers to his family "in any manner whatsoever" was sent back.

  152. S-222

    Northwest Justice Project, WashingtonLawHelp, "I've experienced domestic violence. Should I file a protection order?" (reviewed June 11, 2026)

    Advocacy organization resource · Washington · 2026

    Lists plain examples of coercive control, including threatening to blackmail you.

  153. S-223

    Judicial Council of California, Judges Guide to Restraining Orders: Domestic Violence Restraining Orders (Oct 2023)

    Judicial bench guide · California · 2023

    California's guide for judges says an order can be granted with no physical violence and no threat of it.

  154. S-224

    Mass. Executive Office of Public Safety and Security, press release on updated domestic violence law enforcement guidelines (Oct 17, 2025)

    Government press release · Massachusetts · 2025

    Updated statewide guidelines for police responses to domestic violence include coercive control; Jane Doe Inc. supported them.

  155. S-226

    Illinois HB 1808 (102nd G.A., 2021)

    Bill · Illinois · 2021

    Filed in 2021; did not pass.

  156. S-227

    Illinois HB 3292 (102nd G.A., 2021)

    Bill · Illinois · 2021

    Filed in 2021; did not pass.

  157. S-228

    Illinois HB 5474 (103rd G.A., 2024)

    Bill · Illinois · 2024

    Filed in 2024; did not pass.

  158. S-229

    Illinois State Bar Association, Bar News, "Not Under Control" (Apr. 25, 2022)

    Bar association article · Illinois · 2022

    "But that doesn't mean the concept is invisible within Illinois' legal framework."

  159. S-231

    Illinois Coalition Against Domestic Violence, "Are You Experiencing Abuse?" (for the coalition's name and the state hotline on the companion page)

    Advocacy organization resource · Illinois · 2026

    Cited for the coalition's name and its state hotline.

  160. S-233

    State Law Atlas (this site): the series' state-by-state law tracker, corrected Nov 13, 2026

    This series' own tracker · United States · 2026

    The series' own state-by-state tracker, shown on this site as the State Law Atlas. Every row carries the date it was checked.